2017-01-29

Halleh Farangi - Clearwater


Theft of an animal

PI Jamie Katz with Kai Kassar and Stacey Ribeau

2017-01-29

<<<<>Look Who's Home<>>>>

Missing for 13 Days in Orlando, FL and rehomed in Clearwater, FL... Layla is now SAFE & HOME!!! Here is Layla’s story, told by her owner Kai.

Hello Jamie,
Before I tell Layla's story of how she went missing, I would like to thank you Jamie Katz and the members of Conway Orlando Community, Conway Critters, Stacey Ribeau, Orlando PD, Katrina Evans, Scott Reigel and Clearwater PD for the work care and support you all showed.

My English is not 100% perfect but here is my story. When I first got Layla from her previous owner in Georgia in the beginning of December 2016 she was neglected. Layla used to live in a big farm and was not allowed to stay inside the house, she had ticks, fleas, hook worm, heart worm and an eye infection. Layla was responding to the treatment very fast and within 2-3 weeks Layla was becoming healthier and very happy. On Saturday January 14th, my wife and I went out for dinner, it was around 9pm. We took the kids with us to drop them at my wife's friends house to baby sit them and we all came back home around 11:30pm. When I parked the car, I stepped out and I could see the sliding glass door open. I knew right away that Layla was gone. I walked around the apartment complex hoping Layla was still out there but she wasn't. The next day we went out looking for her at Pet Alliance in Sanford and Orlando but we couldn't find her. I posted her picture on Conway Orlando Community and Conway Critics hoping someone would tell me information about her.

A couple hours had gone by and then a guy messaged me saying my dog was on craigslist. The guy that posted the add left his name & his phone number. Stacey & I responded to the add but he replied saying he already had my dog scanned for a microchip and he found the owner. I replied saying my dog is not microchipped, after a half day of me calling and texting him, he finally answered my phone call. I asked him if I can have my dog back, I told him that I have a proof she's mine and he said he gave her to his friend in Clearwater, Florida. He gave me her name, her phone number and he asked me to keep him out of this. I called the woman right away but she rejected my call but she texted me and said she would rather text. She wanted to know everything about my dog, she wanted pictures, shot records, my wanted to know my dogs name and her description… but at the end she said that it was not my dog. She then blocked me from being able to contact her and everyone who tried to tell her that it was my dog got blocked too.

I called Orlando PD and asked for an officer to write a police report, thirty minutes later a police officer was on my door and Stacey showed up too. Five days later my case was still not solved, everything was happening very slow and then Stacy called me with a new plan. Stacey said she knows that if I hired PI Jamie Katz, that she will bring your dog back. I called Jamie, hired her and within a couple hours Jamie had a complete plan for me to follow. Jamie set up everything I needed to do in order to get my dog back from this woman, all I had to do was follow Jamie’s instructions 100%.

I drove to Clearwater, FL on January 26th, I got there around 8:30 pm. I called the Clearwater PD and told them I needed an officer to meet me and help me get my stolen dog back. The Officer asked me to show him the proof that the dog this woman had in her home was Layla and proof that Layla was my dog. I showed all proof Jamie said we needed and the Police Officer knocked on her door. She answered the door and the look on her face was as if she was surprised that we were here. She started with, “Sir, this guy threatened me”. The police officer looked at me and said, “did you”? I said no. The only defense this woman was saying for days was that my dog was skinny and said I threatened her. She said nothing in response and the police officer said let's not get into this and that we are all adult here. The officer than asked for her to bring the dog outside and then she said the dog has been abused. The officer said if the dog shows signs that she is fears me, then we will do something about that too. The officer wanted to see if I was the owner by Layla’s response once she saw me. The woman insisted that she was looking for the dog’s owner but all these people were trying to claim her including myself. I told the officer that I tried to show her proof that she is mine but she wanted to keep her. There were a lot of people online trying to help me but she blocked them all from contacting her as well. The officer then said, “please ma'am, bring the dog outside”. She went inside and brought Layla out on leash. Layla saw me and she started walking toward me wagging her tail but the woman was holding the leash tight. The officer asked her to drop the leash on the ground but she didn't want to, she was holding Layla’s leash was not wanting to let go. The officer then said, “may I”, and took the leash from her hand and dropped it on the ground. That's when Layla ran to me! I was checking her all over to see if she was okay and she was. She was dirty and had a lot of dirt in her ears and then…I noticed that her two white nails on her left rear foot were painted with black nail polish to try and change her toe nail color from white to black. I told this woman that Layla had two white toe nails when she asked me to prove this dog was mine and she used that to try and fool me!!!

I was so happy to be holding my baby and to finally have her back. I called my family and told them all that we got Layla back, I then called Jamie Katz and Stacey and thanked them over and over.
- Kai Kassar in Orlando, FL

PI Jamie Katz

2017-01-29

<<<<<>Awareness Post<>>>>>

I have heard one or two stories of a missing dogs hair being dyed in order to disguise the dog from the owner. In my experience this is not common but I am here to let you know it does in fact happen and it's sick!
A couple days ago I was messaging back and forth with a woman in her late 20's. This woman's friend had given her a lost dog almost 2 weeks prior and she was not looking for the owner. This woman told me that she was only holding on to this dog because she did not want to give the dog to someone pretending to be the dogs owner... I understood that and now I was here to give her all the proof in the world that she had my clients dog.
I sent vet records, a photo of my client with his dog and I told her that the dog's left rear foot had two white toes & toenails. Besides the fact that my client hired me to get his dog back, this woman still would not cooperate or believe this was the same dog.

I don't want to ruin the found story but we got the police to step in and we were able to reunite the dog with the owner…

My client called me as soon as he got his dog back and he was ecstatic!!! He was telling me all that transpired with the police officer, the woman, all that was said and then he said, "she painted my dogs toenails". My first thought was ohhhh... she loved the dog and that's why no proof was good enough for this girl. Well I was wrong because she did NOT paint this dogs toenails pink, she painted the dogs toenails black!!!!

I have now had my first case of someone trying to change the appearance of a missing dog in order to keep the dog from it's owner. My mind is officially blown and I will post this story in the next couple hours...

Image may contain: 2 people, people smiling, people riding bicycles, outdoor and text

DNA Florida

The contents of this file has been taken from public sources and first-hand accounts and is for informational purposes only; and not to be considered a legal document.

___



2017-01-27

Theresa Ink (aka: Theresa Desilets-Ink) - Lee County


Illegally withheld dog from owner for almost 30 days
Taken Jan 27, 2017 - Returned Feb 24, 2017

LEGAL REGISTRATIONS

Sunbiz

Theresa Ink, President

Florida Department of Agriculture: CH32121

IRS EIN: 94-3467822



TIMELINE

Jan 27, 2017 - Fred taken by Theresa Ink

Jan 30, 2017

Jan 31, 2017

Feb 1, 2017

Feb 2, 2017

Feb 5, 2017


Feb 24, 2017 - Fred reunited with Dave!!

ASSOCIATIONS

Theresa Ink former board member with Carrie Cagata of “My Best Friend” who was arrested and charged with 120 counts of animal cruelty.




NEWS STORIES

Lee County animal adoption center refuses to return dog to owner [video]

February 14, 2017

Lee County man to battle animal adoption center for dog [video]

February 15, 2017

FORT MYERS, Fla. A Lee County animal adoption center refused to return a dog to its owner after someone turned it in. Now, an attorney has offered to help the owner get his dog back.


GoFundMe  - Bring Fred the Dog Home



Elyse Nancy Berman, friend of Dave the owner, is who started the GFM



FACEBOOK POSTS

WINK FB thread


Ana Campos The friend of the owner confirmed by phone that yes she had a problem with him having cancer and they, the owner and her and their side believe she is anti gay. The friend told me there are a lot of people contacting her or them that live there who are very upset. Said more stuff coming out. That Theresa was wealthy and bought that building and that there is no vet really there. That certain people believe she's doing procedures and she's claimed to be a vet. Weird stuff like that. Previous owner adopter is willing to testify about her doing a procedure in their pet herself and the dog got sick. I need to clarify that one. But she said that's what a lot of people think is happening.

Ana Campos Theresa also seems to be psychotic. Like she said the dog was locked in a car and she had to go rescue the dog and break the window. So they got the surveillance out to show her it's not true. Then she changed her mind. The guy adopted another dog from her Peanut from Louisiana floods. She brought In those dogs. She told him she has no idea what he's talking about and that Peanut was not adopted to him from her. Again he has the contract and Paperwork.
___
Ana Campos I spoke to Elise the friend of Dave the owner just now. She said he had chemo therapy treatment today and is feeling very down. I gave her an attorney name that was given to me. They are filing a report with the police for fraud since the Theresa Ink of PPaws Leecountylied and said they were the owner. Also for theft since she said they were returning him and then didn't. They sold him to someone else who called the chip company and tried to change the chip info. The chip company called him and told him. He refused to allow it. So out there is a new owner who knows there is a problem. All that is fraud, theft and trafficking in stolen property.

The rescue did say they don't like him having this many chemo treatments and it's believed she does have a problem with him being gay and in a gay bar. That's what even they believe and discriminating against this man for having cancer or being gay is horrific.
___
Ana Campos Is anyone familiar with PetTrac? This chip company received a call from the new owners of Fred trying to switch the chip info to them. Then they wouldn't disclose who they were to the owner of the chip.

Ana Campos I spoke to the chip company and told them the dog was stolen and who tried to change it?

It was Theresa Ink of PAWS that tried to change the chip info on Jan 30 at 9:53am.
___
Ana Campos Hi XXX

I see that you are on the Board of Directors for PAWS Lee County. Im not sure if you are aware of this viral video doing the rounds??

I'd like for you to please intervene. This man has cancer and it appears as though Theresa Ink
committed fraud when she pretended to be the owner of his lost dog. She said she would return Fred and then sold him. She specifically said she doesn't approve of the disabled owner with cancer having several chemo treatments. He purchased the dog in September and there is a bill of sale. When you find lost property in Florida you have to return it or it is considered grand theft and then conversion.

People are boycotting PAWS and not donating to a organization who pretty much is discriminating against a gay man that has cancer and was in a gay bar. I believe there will be a protest tomorrow. I'm pretty sure the police and an attorney will be involved this week for theft of this dog.

Do you have any comments and would you be willing to negotiate the return if this dog? I would love to see a happy ending and this organization do the right thing by this poor man.

The news is doing a follow up story and it would be great to resolve this amicably.

Please let me know.
Thank you so much!!

Ana Campos Response from one and my response.:

Hello Ana. Your email was the first I heard of this situation. While I am a board member, I serve the group in an advisory capaity. Theresa Ink is the driving force behind it. I have known her for 20 years and I can tell you that her motivation is always to ensure that the animals get the best care possible. I spoke to her and she said that this man did not fulfill the terms of the contract and was extremely abusive to her. She does not care whether someone is gay or straight -- I know this because we have mutual close friends who are gay. She didn't even know the bar was a gay club. That isn't the problem here. I am telling you this for background, not to be quoted for a news story. Theresa is the spokesperson for this organization. This is an unfortunate situation and, as someone who has had cancer twice, I am sorry that he has to deal with that, too, but this is not something I can fix.

Ana Campos The Board is liable.

She did state she had an issue with his chemo and that is discrimination. I have no reason to make that up. She freely admits it. The police are involved because it is theft.

Theresa fraudulently posed as the owner Karen. She is not the owner. The contact is a purchase and there is a bill of sale. The contract is not a co-ownership like it was a vehicle purchase with co-owners and co-signers. It is a purchase. Dave owns that dog and animals are considered property.

What she did was in violation of state property statutes 705.102 and 705.104. They clearly state when you find lost property you must file a police report and surrender it upon request. There is a 90 day custodial period before the property becomes the finders. Should the finder refuse to relinquish the found property they commit grand theft and the severity is based upon several factors.

I've attached the statutes. The dog was not 'co-owned'. It is the property of Mr. Cunningham. That is where Theresa has also made a huge unlawful error.

If there were any issue, you know and she knows, she would have to go to court to enforce a 'contract dispute'.

It is not finders keepers. When she misrepresented herself as the owner she committed fraud. She acquired this 'lost property' by misrepresenting herself. When she said she would return the dog to the owner and then refused she committed grand theft. When she sold the property it is dealing in stolen property. That statute is 812.019

I assure you she has not told you the truth. I strongly suggest you have a lawyer educate her on the laws she broke. The police are involved and a lawsuit is being filed against her.

Ana Campos Karen,

I spoke to the chip company and we feel there is enough evidence to arrest Theresa. They advised me that Theresa Ink of PAWS called the chip company pretending to be the owner and tried to change the chip info on Jan 30 at 9:53am after stealing this dog. The dog was stolen. It is grand theft Karen.

I strongly suggest you be the voice of reason here with her and let Theresa know she committed grand theft and the family is pursuing an arrest. The news will be doing more stories.

Here are two other examples of rescues I helped get arrested based on those statutes. They found a lost dog and tried to play finders keepers or circumvent the court process. Theresa can not circumvent the court process. What she did was illegal and we will go above and beyond to make sure she is arrested.

Shawntavia Nelson was arrested in Palm Beach County in 2016.

Dr. Jill Levine of Atlas Animal Rescue was arrested for doing the exact same thing Theresa Ink has done. She had an adoption contract / bill of sale. You can't circumvent the judicial system and play finders keepers. She refused to return the dog and was arrested.

DNA Florida
The contents of this file has been taken from public sources and first-hand accounts and is for informational purposes only; and not to be considered a legal document.

2017-01-06

Michelle Ashley Barbee & Justin Geoffrey Kates - Tavares

Theft of an animal

Dognappers Arrested After Stealing Puppy from Animal Shelter

January 6, 2017

TAVARES – A couple found themselves behind bars Friday evening after stealing an 8-month-old puppy from the Lake County Sheriff’s Animal Shelter Thursday afternoon according to deputies.

Justin Geoffrey Kates, 28, and Michelle Ashley Barbee, 29, were caught on video surveillance at the animal shelter as they walked out with the puppy.

According to officials at the shelter, the puppy, Kendrick, was in a restricted area that is normally behind a locked door recuperating after being neutered. His adopted family was scheduled to pick him up later that day.

It is unclear as to why the couple stole the puppy or how they gained access to the restricted room.

After posting the incident on their Facebook fan page, deputies received numerous tips that led to Kates and Barbee.

2017-01-01

PUPPY PALACE & Judith Ann Norford - Hollywood

PUPPY PALACE & Judith Ann Norford - Hollywood

8961 Taft Street Pembroke Pines 33024
954-404-8757

Retail puppy store selling sick animals

2017-01-01

NEWS STORIES

Florida Lawsuit


Attorney MARCY I. LAHART, ESQ has filed suit against Puppy Palace in Boynton Beach and Hollywood Florida, Wizard of Claws in Pembroke Pines, Florida and Precious Puppies in Palm Beach, Florida. The lawsuit alleges that "the stores misrepresented the health and origins of the puppies sold to the defendants and violated the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and consumer protection laws. The suit seek preliminary and permanent injuctions that would prohibit the stores from furture sales of puppies as well as reimbursement for the price of the puppies, veterinary bills, legal costs and punitive damages." If you have purchased a dog from one of these stores, worked at one of these stores or have any information about the stores, please contact the attorney at:

Marcy I. LaHart, PA.
711 Talladega Street
West Palm Beach, FL 33405
(561) 655-9537
milahart@bellsouth.net
Sickly Pets Lead Dog Owners To Sue Puppy Palace
Nine Plaintiffs Seek To Be Reimbursed For The Price Of Their Animals And For Veterinary Costs.
October 31, 2003|By Daniella Aird Staff Writer

A group of pet owners sued a South Florida puppy store Thursday, saying the business sold them animals ridden with contagious diseases, genetic disorders and other health problems.
Lawsuits were filed in Broward and Palm Beach circuit courts against Puppy Palace Inc., a pet store with locations in Hollywood and Boynton Beach. The customers claim it violates state law because it misrepresents the quality of its puppies.
According to the lawsuits, which allege fraud and breach of warranty, nine plaintiffs -- eight in Palm Beach County and one in Broward -- seek to be reimbursed for the price of their dogs, as well as the veterinary expenses they incurred while caring for the sick animals. The lawsuit also asks the court to stop Puppy Palace from selling puppies.
Puppy Palace owner Judy Norford could not be contacted for comment Thursday, despite several attempts to reach her by phone at her Hollywood store.
Plaintiff April Wolf, a Boynton Beach resident, said that when she bought Zoe, her Australian cattle dog, at the pet store in March 2002, she was told the puppy came from a private breeder in Fort Lauderdale. Zoe suffered from all sorts of health problems, including pneumonia and mange, according to the lawsuit. Her symptoms ranged from coughing and diarrhea, to fever and runny nose.
Wolf says she later learned her canine came from a Missouri puppy mill that has been repeatedly cited by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
"I was so angry. It's not like they're ripping off people with cars. These are innocent animals," said Wolf, 35, a dental office manager who says she spent more than $2,000 in vet bills to care for Zoe. "It's disgusting. I don't know how these people can do this. It isn't fair because I was lied to."
West Palm Beach attorney Marcy LaHart, who is representing the pet owners, said her clients were defrauded because Puppy Palace misrepresents from where its puppies come. Puppy mills turn out canines the way a factory "mass-produces widgets," she said.

Dog with rare congenital condition purchased from Hollywood pet store
Owner saddled with medical bills after purchasing dog from Puppy Palace
By Jacey Birch - Anchor/Animal Advocate
Posted: 11:20 PM, February 09, 2015

HOLLYWOOD, Fla. - We've all heard the warnings about buying puppies from pet stores. In some cases the dogs are brought in by backyard breeders or purchased from puppy mills.
But as Local 10 News animal advocate Jacey Birch found out, instead of buying food and toys, new owners could be saddled with a sick animal and mounting medical bills.
Kevin Graver always adopted shelter dogs in the past, but not this time.
"We've been going to Puppy Palace in Hollywood probably for the last 20 years, looking at puppies," said Graver. "We went in there one day and we saw Helga, and we fell in love with her so we purchased her."
But the love affair quickly turned into a medical nightmare.
"As soon as we took her home, we noticed something was wrong," Graver said. "It wasn't that she wasn't housebroken yet, it was just that she was, like, leaking all the time."
It was a rare congenital condition called ectopic ureter, where a connection to the bladder is missing.
"She has to have a diaper on constantly, because it's been a year and a half of pee all over the house, and having to wash the bed stuff every day and wet towels," said Graver.
Three surgeries later and the English bulldog still has to be dressed like a baby, kept in a cage and injected with medicine twice a day.
"Even though she went out and peed, there's a long trail of urine here," said Graver. "This is the new antibiotic she's on."
Even with all these efforts, it still may not be enough.
"We've already been told she's going to have a very short life," Graver said. "She's probably going to have infection after infection until she has kidney failure."
"What has your communication with Puppy Palace been like?" asked Birch.
"It was decent in the beginning," Graver said.
When Graver purchased Helga from Puppy Palace, he spent about $1,300. But since then he's paid twenty times that amount just in Helga's medical bills.
"It looks like we paid $5,000 that day," said Graver.
By law, Puppy Palace had to give back the price of the dog, and it did. But Graver is suspicious the pet shop is aware of these reproduction repercussions.
"They know they are breeding unhealthy dogs with medical conditions that will pass on to the puppies, and they breed them anyway," Graver said.
Local 10 went to the pet shop in Hollywood, but nobody wanted to answer our questions.
"I just wanted to ask whoever is in charge about the sick puppies. We're hearing that there are sick puppies that are sold here," Birch said. "Can you just tell me about the accusations that have been made? Do you buy from puppy mills?"
Local 10 was asked to leave. Puppy Palace told Birch it was closed.
"You're closed? Are you closed because we're here?" asked Birch.
"No, not at all," a Puppy Palace employee said.
But problems with Puppy Palace are not new. Protests outside the 25-year-old pet shop, dozens of lawsuits and Better Business Bureau filings have all accused the owners of selling sick puppies and buying from backyard breeders or puppy mills. Even a Yelp review page is filled with complaints.
Hallandale Beach City Commissioner and animal advocate Michele Lazarow is fighting city by city to abolish the retail sale of cats and dogs.
"They are inbred, overbred, they live their lives in squalor, they're sick and they arrive to the stores sick," said Lazarow. "The reason I started this work is because I, in 2004, bought a dog from Puppy Palace. The dog was sick, ultimately, and I had 10 years of medical issues and medical bills, and he died this year."
Florida is leading the way -- 35 municipalities in the state have decided to change the way pets are purchased, changes Graver hopes can come soon and save others from the heartaches he's endured with Helga.
"How do you feel that Helga may have been a puppy mill puppy?" asked Birch.
"I feel awful because she's had a terrible life," Graver said. "If Puppy Palace and all other pet shops can be closed, at least nobody else would have to go through this in the future, which would be a good thing."
Helga had a close call last week, but an emergency vet visit saved her life.

Below is a list of Florida cities banning the retail sale of cats and/or dogs:

ARRESTS-CHARGES


Judith Ann Norford

Hollywood, FL
07/22/2016 - OUT-OF-CNTY/WARRANT
DOB: 06/28/1961
Offener ID: AT40287085501961062820160722

Puppy Palace


Troy E Terrebonne vs. Puppy Palace
Damages $100 - $2500
01-19-1995
Disposed
Ronald Burg , et al vs. Puppy Palace
Damages $100 - $2500
01-19-1995
Disposed
Joan Marie Schapler vs. Puppy Palace
CC Damages >$5K - $15
02-25-1997
Disposed
Carlos Gonzalez vs. Puppy Palace
Contract & Indebtedness
04-22-1997
Disposed
Stacey Cote vs. Puppy Palace
Small Claims +
04-08-2002
Disposed
Karen Valente vs. Judy Norford
Tem/Perm Injunction
11-03-2003
Reopened - CV
Paul Braxton , et al vs. Puppy Palace
Small Claims +
06-06-2006
Disposed
Richard J Zaden vs. Puppy Palace
Small Claims +
01-11-2007
Disposed
Christina Cafiero vs. Puppy Palace
Small Claims +
01-15-2014
Disposed
Pethealth Services vs. Puppy Palace
CC Damages >$5K - $15
11-19-2014
Reclosed Case
Marcella Sheck vs. Puppy Palace
Neg - Premises Liability Commercial
11-24-2015
Pending